Re: NS Mafia Round 1

[Dtewi]

Uhhh... ummm...

Damn, the cop can't come forward. Now all we have is intuition.

I am a bit intrigued. Maybe Mako was shifting votes away from damkira and started a new bandwagon vote for Dgc.

I mean, damkira already had a couple votes and he basically wanted a random lynch so why not go for him?

Vote: Mako

[Mako]

You guys suck. Someone could have atleast PM'd me...

Bad zombie, go back to your grave! (Sorry)

[Mako]

Uhhh... ummm...

Damn, the cop can't come forward. Now all we have is intuition.

I am a bit intrigued. Maybe Mako was shifting votes away from damkira and started a new bandwagon vote for Dgc.

I mean, damkira already had a couple votes and he basically wanted a random lynch so why not go for him?

Vote: Mako

I already said I wanted to get the game moving. I figured voting for the person who seemed to be lurking the most would be a good strategy to get some talking going. I also already said I didn't expect people to put in the final vote before he had a chance to defend himself. If anything, we should blame the last person to vote for him...

[SciFiBoy]

I dunno that we can really blame Mako for yesterday, we all went for the random lynch to get the game moving

[Mako]

SciFi, who do you see as most suspicious from yesterday based on how everyone voted?

I'm thinking Son1x's post was most suspicious, trying to get away with not really saying anything. (Just a hunch though)

[SciFiBoy]

hmm, i'd say its either Son1x or Falcon095. they both joined the bandwagon way too easily/casualy for my liking.

[Mako]

Yeah. And then there are those who didn't vote at all, which also bothers me a little. We need to get more opinions guys.

[El Duderino]

IDK... voting is suspicious... not voting is suspicious... pointing fingers is suspicious... not pointing fingers is suspicious... a few members might look a little more suspect than others but we really don't have any good data to work with here...

[Mako]

IDK... voting is suspicious... not voting is suspicious... pointing fingers is suspicious... not pointing fingers is suspicious... a few members might look a little more suspect than others but we really don't have any good data to work with here...

All because the doctor died. Now the cop can't come forward with info because he risks being killed by the mafia as well. So, basically the cop will wait until he finds out one or two mafia members with a few innocent people being cleared, to tell us what he knows. Until then we have to figure out who the mafia are ourselves based on posts. So, this means it is Luin's fault if we lose.

[Sonix]

Its not like we had anything else to do and since I was one of the first ones to vote, I didn't need to watch out to not lynch him so he can say a word.

Whats a mason again, btw? They know eachother or something, was it?

[Falcon095]

Bad news: we have 2 pro town less
Consolation news: they didnt have key roles

We really have to start discussing to avoid a day/night like that.

Ok, I think you're being a bit too er.. obvious. I mean given that most of the players voted for dgc (probably for the same reason) it's kind of obvious that there must be a mafia among those, the thing is that it'll be pretty difficul and almost random to know who's mafia judging from the votes for dgc, because like I said, everybody voted for "appearently" the same reason.

[c03n3nj0]

Uhhh... ummm...

Damn, the cop can't come forward. Now all we have is intuition.

I am a bit intrigued. Maybe Mako was shifting votes away from damkira and started a new bandwagon vote for Dgc.

I mean, damkira already had a couple votes and he basically wanted a random lynch so why not go for him?

Vote: Mako

I already said I wanted to get the game moving. I figured voting for the person who seemed to be lurking the most would be a good strategy to get some talking going. I also already said I didn't expect people to put in the final vote before he had a chance to defend himself. If anything, we should blame the last person to vote for him...

Wait, how was DGC lurking the most? Or even, more than damkira?

You originally said it was because DGC had voted for me, but now saying that it was because he was lurking the most is just weird...

[Axum]

I find Mako to be the most suspicious honestly...at first I was thinking he could have been a cop hinting he found DGC was guilty.

It also strikes me as odd that he wanted DGC to defend himself but wasn't willing to unvote him to hear what the had to say after seeing that the bandwagon was already almost fully loaded.

(I meant to post this last night but I fell asleep before hitting the send button).

[Axum]

Its not like we had anything else to do and since I was one of the first ones to vote, I didn't need to watch out to not lynch him so he can say a word.

Whats a mason again, btw? They know eachother or something, was it?

IIRC, they can talk to each other at night (which could explain why we are having such long nights). The problem with the Mason role is that in previous games, there have been evil people involved with the masons which have ended up in mason deaths? Or am I getting that role confused with the twins role?

[c03n3nj0]

Its not like we had anything else to do and since I was one of the first ones to vote, I didn't need to watch out to not lynch him so he can say a word.

Whats a mason again, btw? They know eachother or something, was it?

IIRC, they can talk to each other at night (which could explain why we are having such long nights). The problem with the Mason role is that in previous games, there have been evil people involved with the masons which have ended up in mason deaths? Or am I getting that role confused with the twins role?

Yeah, it has happened with Mason roles.

I guess it's up to dsister to have implemented it, but usually having a mafia mason led to whining because it wasn't fair and literally made the masons useless.

In a small game like this I don't think dsister did it, though...

[Mako]

Wait, how was DGC lurking the most? Or even, more than damkira?

You originally said it was because DGC had voted for me, but now saying that it was because he was lurking the most is just weird...

Because I looked and DGC was the one who had not logged in for the longest amount of time. This is lurking to me. I never said that was why I voted for him. I stated why I voted for him when I actually voted.... I said I figured voting for a lurker would lead to more people talking since he would have to come and defend himself.

I find Mako to be the most suspicious honestly...at first I was thinking he could have been a cop hinting he found DGC was guilty.

It also strikes me as odd that he wanted DGC to defend himself but wasn't willing to unvote him to hear what the had to say after seeing that the bandwagon was already almost fully loaded.

(I meant to post this last night but I fell asleep before hitting the send button).

I never hinted I was the cop....and I never said I wasn't willing to unvote DGC, I just figured everyone would leave him and (left-1) until he had a chance to come defend himself, I mean, it is usually what you do.... Guess not.

[Axum]

Yeah, it has happened with Mason roles.

I guess it's up to dsister to have implemented it, but usually having a mafia mason led to whining because it wasn't fair and literally made the masons useless.

In a small game like this I don't think dsister did it, though...

I would hope not but anything is possible.

This whole not having a doctor thing is increasingly painful on this game since it ruins a great idea I had involving the masons class. x.o

I am assuming we have at least 3 Masons in this game, which means if the cop emerges (later on during the game of course) and states that "trucksosaurus (being the example of who was a mason) is innocent" then he could emerge and say who else he "thinks" are innocent. Therefore not breaking any rules by stating anything about being a member of the masons but also confirming in a sense that the other people involved are not guilty, therefore leading to less suspects. I unfortunately do not belong to the Masons but I figure this might help later on during the game.

[Axum]

I find Mako to be the most suspicious honestly...at first I was thinking he could have been a cop hinting he found DGC was guilty.

It also strikes me as odd that he wanted DGC to defend himself but wasn't willing to unvote him to hear what the had to say after seeing that the bandwagon was already almost fully loaded.

(I meant to post this last night but I fell asleep before hitting the send button).

I never hinted I was the cop....and I never said I wasn't willing to unvote DGC, I just figured everyone would leave him and (left-1) until he had a chance to come defend himself, I mean, it is usually what you do.... Guess not.

It was really just a guess you were trying to hint at 1 thing without being obvious about it. DGC was acting very much like DGC acts during these games (which has led to him being lynched early in the game....a lot.) I wish I would have realized that yesterday when we were voting.

[Mako]

It was really just a guess you were trying to hint at 1 thing without being obvious about it. DGC was acting very much like DGC acts during these games (which has led to him being lynched early in the game....a lot.) I wish I would have realized that yesterday when we were voting.

I have been suspicious of DGC in many other games as well for no real reason. But, I remember him being more active that what he has been in this game. I must be remembering wrong...

[Axum]

It was really just a guess you were trying to hint at 1 thing without being obvious about it. DGC was acting very much like DGC acts during these games (which has led to him being lynched early in the game....a lot.) I wish I would have realized that yesterday when we were voting.

I have been suspicious of DGC in many other games as well for no real reason. But, I remember him being more active that what he has been in this game. I must be remembering wrong...

IIRC, this isn't the first time he's been lynched without time to respond. x.o

[Mako]

^^OK then, I think you are right.

(I'm off to work now)

[Mako]

FoS: Everyone for lurking.....

Seriously, we are never going to get anywhere this way. We are playing right into the mafia's hands...

[c03n3nj0]

Wait, how was DGC lurking the most? Or even, more than damkira?

You originally said it was because DGC had voted for me, but now saying that it was because he was lurking the most is just weird...

Because I looked and DGC was the one who had not logged in for the longest amount of time. This is lurking to me. I never said that was why I voted for him. I stated why I voted for him when I actually voted.... I said I figured voting for a lurker would lead to more people talking since he would have to come and defend himself.

You said "Vote: DGC

He wanted to kill Jo. I think he is mafia!"

So I don't get what you mean by "I stated why I voted for him when I actually voted..." Why couldn't you write that you thought it was a lurker then?

My point is that you originally said that sole reason, but now you change it to saying he was lurking... lack of consistency.

Also, I'm surprised the thread managed to die so easily, I thought we would have more to talk about today...

[Mako]

^^Because lurking wasn't the main reason I voted for him.. I voted for him because I found what he said about you to be odd. At the same time I thought it would start more discussion since he was lurking and would have to defend himself... It is not too hard to understand.

[Mako]

Vote: Damkira

Out of everyone left alive he hasn't posted in the longest time. Lurkers will only hurt the town. Especially ones who haven't posted in 15 days.... Kingfate is next with 11....

[Sponsored content]